Top Mistakes First-Time Property Investors Make (and How to Avoid Them)
Buying your first investment property is a big milestone. But while owning a rental can be a great way to build wealth over time, it also comes with risks—and the learning curve can be steep. Many first-time investors make avoidable mistakes that eat into their returns or cause unnecessary stress.
Here’s a look at the most common errors new landlords make, and how to steer clear of them on your path to successful property investment.
1. Focusing on Capital Gains Alone
Many first-time investors fall into the trap of buying a property purely for future value growth, without considering whether it actually makes sense in the short term.
Sure, capital gains can be appealing—but they’re not guaranteed. Property values move in cycles, and if you’ve bought a negatively geared home in a flat market, you might end up with a cashflow crunch and no equity uplift to show for it.
Avoid it by:
Running full cashflow calculations before you buy. Know your expected rental income, mortgage costs, rates, insurance, and maintenance. Can you afford to hold the property if interest rates rise or the market stalls?
2. Not Understanding Bank Lending Rules
It’s not just about whether you can afford a property—it’s whether the bank thinks you can. First-time investors often underestimate how strictly banks assess borrowing for investment properties.
Most lenders will require:
A 35% deposit for existing homes (20% for new builds)
Sufficient income to service both your current home and the new rental
Buffers for rising interest rates
A track record of savings and responsible credit use
Avoid it by:
Talking to a mortgage adviser before you start browsing properties. They’ll help you understand your borrowing power and guide you toward lenders whose criteria match your situation.
3. Forgetting About the Tax Implications
Tax has a major impact on your rental’s performance. With the interest deductibility rule changes, you can’t always offset your mortgage interest against rental income—especially if you're buying an existing property.
Not knowing this can lead to surprise tax bills and kill cashflow. Other tax considerations include depreciation, GST (for some new builds), and ring-fencing rules.
Avoid it by:
Getting advice from an accountant who understands property investment. They’ll help you structure your purchase properly and avoid tax surprises.
4. Overestimating Rent—or Underestimating Costs
A common rookie mistake is assuming your property will always be rented at the high end of the market, with minimal costs. In reality, you need to plan for vacancies, repairs, property management fees, and compliance costs (like Healthy Homes standards).
Even the best tenants can unexpectedly move out, and older homes always need more upkeep than you expect.
Avoid it by:
Using conservative estimates. Base your rental income on the lower end of the market, and allow at least 5–10% of rent for maintenance and 1–2 weeks per year for vacancy.
5. Buying in the Wrong Location
It’s easy to get drawn in by a house that looks like a “bargain,” especially in smaller towns or outer suburbs. But if the rental demand is weak or job opportunities are limited, you could face long vacancies or low-quality tenants.
Avoid it by:
Looking for areas with strong population growth, infrastructure investment, and tenant demand. Proximity to public transport, schools, and amenities can make a big difference in keeping a rental occupied and appealing.
6. Failing to Treat It Like a Business
Property investment isn’t a passive hobby—it’s a business. First-time investors often go in with a casual attitude, forgetting that they’ll need to deal with tenant issues, maintenance problems, cashflow decisions, and long-term planning.
Avoid it by:
Creating a property investment plan. Set clear goals, understand your financials, and have a plan for reviews, maintenance schedules, and when to hold, sell, or refinance.
7. Skipping the Co-Ownership Conversation
Buying with friends, siblings, or parents is becoming more common—but many first-time investors skip the uncomfortable but necessary legal conversations.
Who pays for what? What happens if someone wants out? What if one party can’t pay?
Avoid it by:
Putting a co-ownership agreement in place upfront and speaking to a lawyer who specialises in property investment. It may feel unnecessary when everything is going well, but it will save stress and legal issues down the line.
8. Ignoring the Benefits of New Builds
Some investors are wary of new builds, assuming they’re overpriced or slow to appreciate. But under current rules, new builds come with major advantages: lower deposit requirements, full interest deductibility, and lower maintenance.
Avoid it by:
At least comparing new builds against existing stock. Even if the rental yield looks slightly lower, the tax savings and lower ongoing costs could make it a smarter choice—especially for first-time investors.
9. Not Getting Professional Help
Trying to “go it alone” is admirable—but in property, getting the wrong advice (or none at all) can be expensive. First-time investors sometimes skip mortgage advisers, property managers, and lawyers, thinking they’ll save money.
Avoid it by:
Building your team. A good mortgage adviser can structure your lending more strategically than the bank. A property manager can screen tenants, handle disputes, and free up your time. A lawyer ensures your paperwork is rock-solid.
The small upfront costs often save thousands in the long run.
Get the Foundations Right, and the Growth Will Follow
The property investment journey has many moving parts—but when done well, it can create long-term wealth, security, and passive income. The key is to treat it like a business, understand your numbers, and make smart, informed decisions from day one.
Learning from other people’s mistakes is often the cheapest form of education.
Mortgage Lab’s mission is to be the digital town square for financial decision-makers to gain knowledge about their current and future mortgage. Follow us on Facebook and LinkedIn or subscribe to our newsletter to be notified of our latest articles.