New Build vs Existing Home: Which Should You Buy?
For many Kiwis, one of the first big questions in the home-buying journey is whether to purchase a brand-new home or an existing one. It might come down to practicalities—like budget, location, or timing—or more personal factors, like the character of an old villa or the fresh start of a never-lived-in home. But beyond preferences, there are some significant financial and strategic considerations that can make one option a better fit than the other, especially depending on whether you're a first home buyer or investor.
First Home Buyers: Comparing New Builds and Existing Properties
The Case for Buying a New Build
New builds offer some strong financial incentives for first-time buyers. The First Home Grant is doubled for new builds—up to $10,000 per person, compared to $5,000 for existing homes. If you and a partner are eligible, that’s potentially $20,000 towards your deposit. However, these grants come with price caps that vary by region (ranging from $500,000 to $700,000 for new builds), which can make finding a qualifying property challenging.
New builds typically mean minimal repair or maintenance costs for the foreseeable future—ideal if your DIY skills are limited or your budget is tight. Look for builders offering 10-year guarantees, which provide additional peace of mind.
There’s also the chance to build equity immediately. A section bought for $300,000 and a build costing another $300,000 might be valued at $620,000 or more once complete. This gain, however, might be influenced by general market growth over the build period, so take that into account when running the numbers.
Customisation is another drawcard. If you're building, you can design the home to suit your lifestyle now and appeal to future buyers later. Talk to local real estate agents about what features are in demand so you can build a home that’s both functional and saleable. Just keep in mind that more affordable new builds—such as those designed to meet First Home Grant price caps—are often fixed-plan builds, meaning customisation may be limited.
Why Buy an Existing Home?
If location is your top priority, an existing property might be your only realistic option. The most desirable areas are often fully developed, with little room left for new builds. This makes existing homes more accessible in well-established neighbourhoods close to schools, shops, and transport.
You also gain the ability to negotiate. Vendors may be motivated to sell quickly or their property might need work, which can create opportunities for a lower purchase price. Just remember to budget for repairs if that’s the case.
Buying an existing home generally means a simpler, faster process than building. While building can be hugely rewarding, delays, variations in cost, and decision fatigue are common. If you'd rather avoid the potential stress or don’t have the time or energy to manage a build, buying existing may suit you better.
Property Investors: Which Option is Smarter?
Why New Builds Appeal to Investors
New builds have become increasingly attractive to investors—especially after the 2021 tax changes. The Government began phasing out interest deductibility on existing properties, but new builds are exempt. This gives new builds a significant tax advantage, improving your long-term cash flow.
New properties are also compliant with Healthy Homes Standards by default, saving you from costly upgrades. Things like ventilation systems, double glazing, insulation, and heating are all already in place.
And just like for homeowners, the low-maintenance nature of a new property means fewer repair costs and lower management overhead in the first 5–10 years.
On top of that, you can design a new build with renters in mind. Think durable materials, easy-care landscaping, and layouts that work for flatmates, families, or professionals. If you're building in a popular rental area—near universities or transport hubs—this can make your property highly desirable to tenants.
Where Existing Properties Still Win
Despite the tax disadvantage, existing properties can still offer strong upside—particularly if you’re willing to roll up your sleeves. Buying a do-up at a discount and renovating strategically can generate immediate equity. In some cases, you may even be able to add a second dwelling, which could then qualify as a “new build” for tax purposes (check with your accountant first).
Upgrades like converting a garage to a sleepout, adding off-street parking, fencing a yard for families, or improving insulation can all enhance the property’s appeal and rental yield. And buying existing often gives you more location choice, especially in mature suburbs with strong rental demand.
If your strategy is buy-renovate-sell, existing homes may provide a faster turnaround and more profit potential—especially in a rising market.
The Financial Mechanics of Building
Building a new home introduces two main financial structures: turn-key contracts and progress payment contracts. Turn-key contracts require only a small deposit up front, with the remainder paid upon completion. Progress payment contracts, however, require staged payments as the build progresses. This can mean paying both rent and part of your mortgage during the build period, which might stretch your budget.
For a full comparison, see our guide: Construction Mortgages – Turn Key vs Progress Payment Contracts.
What’s Right for You?
As with most property decisions, the answer comes down to your personal circumstances, finances, and risk appetite. If you’re after a low-maintenance, tax-advantaged investment or a fresh, energy-efficient first home, new builds are hard to beat. If location, charm, or renovation potential matter more—and you’re up for a bit of work—then an existing home may offer better value.
Just don’t forget the golden rule: if your partner has their heart set on a stained-glass villa, you may find the debate over before it even begins.
Mortgage Lab’s mission is to be the digital town square for financial decision-makers to gain knowledge about their current and future mortgage. Follow us on Facebook and LinkedIn or subscribe to our newsletter to be notified of our latest articles.